We are Open M-F 8AM-6PM | SAT 9AM-3PM

(605) 641-1770

Menu

Preserving Charm: A Guide to Choosing the Right Roof for Your Historic Home


Living in a historic home is like owning a piece of history. From unique architectural details to original craftsmanship, these homes have character you can’t find in new construction. However, when it’s time for a roof replacement, choosing the right materials and techniques to maintain your home’s historic integrity is essential. Here’s a guide to help you navigate this process and make informed choices.

1. consider the home’s original roofing materials

Older homes were often topped with materials specific to their period and region, such as wood shakes, slate tiles, or clay tiles. Preserving the original material (or closely matching it) helps maintain the home’s historical appeal. Plus, modern versions of these materials often offer greater durability and longevity, providing the best of both worlds. Research or consult a professional to find out what materials would have been used when your home was first built.

2. choose compatible, high-quality modern materials

For many historic homes, it’s possible to find materials that offer a modern upgrade while preserving the original aesthetic. For example:

  • Composite or Synthetic Slate Tiles: These tiles mimic the look of natural slate but weigh less and often cost significantly less.
  • Metal Roofing: Metal roofs were commonly used on Victorian and Gothic-style homes and can still be an excellent choice. Today’s metal roofing can be crafted to resemble other materials while offering enhanced durability.
  • Architectural Shingles: Modern asphalt shingles come in styles that mimic wood shakes or slate, blending in beautifully with traditional aesthetics.

3. work with a contractor who specializes in historic roof restoration

Historic roofing projects require a careful approach, especially when handling unique architectural features. Working with a contractor experienced in historic home roofing ensures that they will understand the challenges associated with older buildings, such as preserving unique eaves, dormers, or chimneys. At LaPrade Roofing, we’ve had years of experience restoring roofs on historic homes. We take pride in helping homeowners maintain the structural integrity of their homes while enhancing curb appeal.

4. focus on durability and weather resistance

In regions like the Black Hills, where hail and extreme weather are common, selecting a roof material with good durability and weather resistance is essential. Historic homes often have unique structural considerations, and protecting these homes from weather damage helps them stand the test of time. Opt for materials with Class 4 impact resistance, which can stand up to hail, high winds, and other weather elements, giving you peace of mind without compromising your home’s look.

5. look for potential tax credits and preservation grants

Preserving historic homes is highly encouraged, and many states offer financial incentives to help owners cover restoration costs. South Dakota, for example, may offer grants or tax credits to preserve historic structures. Be sure to look into any available preservation grants or incentives before beginning a roof replacement project. These funds can help offset the cost of high-quality, historically accurate materials.

The Roof Matters: Preserve Your Historic Home’s Character

A roof isn’t just about protection; it’s also a defining feature of your home’s aesthetic. Choosing the right materials and working with skilled professionals makes all the difference. Whether your goal is to preserve historic integrity, improve durability, or enhance curb appeal, LaPrade Roofing is here to help you bring your vision to life. Reach out for a free consultation, and let’s discuss how to restore your home’s roof with care and expertise.

Recent Articles

Back to Blog
Uncategorized

How to Spot a Leak
A leaky roof can cause major damage if not addressed quickly. Here’s how to identify a leak before it becomes...
Discover More
Uncategorized

Preparing for Storm Season
Hail season can cause serious damage to your roof if you’re not prepared. Here are some steps to ensure your...
Discover More
Uncategorized

Did You Know - Roofing Color Science
Choosing the right shingle color isn’t just about aesthetics—it can affect your home’s energy efficiency, longevity, and curb appeal. Here’s...
Discover More
Complete Home Improvement Solutions
Ready to Transform Your Home?
Built to Endure, Designed to Impress
Our Craftsmanship in Action

View More

What our customers are saying
Customer Reviews
I’m a licensed builder in Wyoming (Evergreen Hills Construction). I subcontracted with LaPrade to install roofing and siding on a new home I am building. The homeowners and I were impressed with Jonathan’s professional and friendly interactions with us as we worked out pricing and as the job was completed....
Jon S.
Google Review
I had an excellent experience with Tim Bolt and his company, LaPrade Roofing, in Spearfish. The hail storm of June 4, 2020 badly damaged both my home and shop roofs. LaPrade Roofing was recommended by a friend and did a great job replacing my asphalt roofs. Tim has an experienced...
Scott S.
Google Review
Jonathan was fabulous to work with. Our roof was done in less than a week after signing the contract. The roof was done in less than 2 days. The crew were very hard workers and they did a fantastic job. Thank you.
Cheryl B.
Google Review
Tim is great to work with! He is quick to respond and very informative about the work his crew is doing! I highly recommend to anybody in the spearfish area looking to get a new roof!
Cole S.
Google Review
We had a roof leak around a skylight and LaPrade was able to quickly diagnose the problem, identify two other areas that were leaking, and make necessary repairs that same week. A few months later, we suspected that additional repairs should be done and contracted with LaPrade to do these,...
Jean F.
Google Review
Could not have asked for a better experience. Tim was great to work with and explained things clearly. The team was efficient and did quality work. Our insurance company even praised them for their clear and concise communication. I will tell everyone I know to check out LaPrade!
Tanya F.
Google Review
I have hired LaPrade Roofing to replace 2 damaged roofs on 2 different properties about 8 years apart. The advice on products appears to have been spot on as both roofs look great and are in excellent condition, even the older one which still looks like new after numerous hailstorms...
Audrey B.
Google Review
We hired LaPrade Roofing and Restoration for two major projects on our new build. We had them complete our roof and our Diamond Kote Smart Siding. Our home was relatively large and had a complex roof (12/12 pitch with dormers). They did excellent work. They were on time and completed...
Karen
Google Review
I highly recommend this company for your roofing needs. The owner, Tim Boldt, is very responsive in terms of returning calls, and he checks in before and during the time the work is being done. His crew finished our three-story house in one day, and they worked 12 hours to...
Susan H.
Google Review
I had Laprade Construction, Tim Boldt, replace the hail damaged roof on my home – this is the 2nd time they did work for me as they also worked on our rental. The entire process was painless- organized with the paperwork, replacement samples, terrific explanation of all stages & made...
Joe G.
Google Review
My recent experience with LaPrade Roofing and Restoration was entirely positive, as was an earlier 2017-2018 interaction after considerable home damage from wind and hail. The recent job was a minor roof repair involving considerable travel to replace or reposition a few concrete roof tiles; however, I needed the work...
Leslie H.
Google Review
After trying to get a hold of several other contractors to do my roof, Tim was quick to get my roof done and even gave me pointers to work with insurance company.
Jesse H.
Google Review
LaPrade roofing did a great job on our 36 unit apartment complex. They were efficient, professional and very good to work with. They did what they said they would, when they said they would do it. They got our job done on time even though there was a blizzard that...
Hank P.
Google Review

Summerset, SD

Sundance, WY

Gillette, WY